Why I Stopped Making Halloween Costumes

Let me tell you a story about why I no longer make my kids' Halloween costumes. Growing up, my mom always made our costumes. We had no money, but my mom was also an amazing sewist and now does this professionally. A core memory was winning the costume contest at the local movie theatre dressed as a Hershey's Kiss. It was really epic!
Flash forward to my own kids. I actually really loved sewing and making the cutest Halloween costumes. In the age of Pinterest, the sky was the limit. My oldest would get super into this process, and her excitement also made the creativity from me feel so rewarding. It was also so fun for others to see the work I put in and the fun and original costumes we came up with. Even though I was up until midnight the night before, finishing so she could have it for school the next day, I truly felt like I was doing something I loved.

A few years later came her little sister. A new baby to dress to match big sister! I felt like we were leveling up! Well, the joke was on me, because this little sensory bundle was not going to have it. It took two years of her refusing to wear the costumes and instead going trick-or-treating in her Halloween pajamas before it felt like time to rethink my investment.
As I started to explore my own needs related to creating these Halloween costumes, I realized that I really had loved this tradition in the past, but it was increasingly feeling like an obligation. This is often what traditions become. I was no longer doing it for the love of expressing my creativity but instead because it was something I had always done. Something that had been done for me.
I have since learned that I have ADHD, and looking back, this project asked a lot of my brain. The planning. Guessing how long it would really take (never long enough). The hyperfocus that kept me at the sewing machine until midnight. When I'm choosing something I love, that's a trade I'm happy to make. When it's out of obligation, it takes precious resources away from the things that actually light me up now.
In working with others, with and without ADHD, I do find that this dynamic can be one of the hardest to navigate. Especially when it comes to the holidays, we carry so many ideas, expectations, and judgments about what needs to be done and how. We also put so much pressure on ourselves to create the magic that we selectively remember from our own childhood. In the story about the costume contest, I fail to remember how much I hated getting up on stage in front of everyone, as I was a shy and easily overstimulated kid. (I once peed my pants in kindergarten because I was too afraid to raise my hand and ask to go to the bathroom.) I also fail to remember the exhaustion I would feel during and after one of these hyperfocused costume-making sessions, and how little I actually wanted to go trick-or-treating that night.
The moral of the story is this: our traditions deserve an honest look. Is this still where I want to spend my time, attention, and energy? That's a hard question to ask when mama guilt walks into the room. But your energy is part of the cost, and so is the version of you that's left over when it's all done. Taking care of ourselves is usually the first thing we put on a shelf so we can take care of everyone else.
So here is my question for you: Which traditions are you keeping because you love them, and which are you keeping because you always have? Maybe some can go. Maybe some can stay and just get smaller, or easier. My friend Imani once told me that "for every yes, there has to first be a no to make space for it." This work frees us up to actually invest in the things that do light us up and make us the most vibrant version of ourselves.
Let's do the holidays different this year.
If you want some company sorting out which traditions stay, shrink, or go this year, I'm hosting The Low-Demand Holiday, a 3-week coaching group. Less making magic for everyone else, and a little more for you.
Tuesdays, December 1, 8, and 15, noon Central on Zoom. Every session is recorded. $199, and the full $199 counts toward January's group if you want to keep going. Enrollment closes Friday, November 27.



Comments